31 Days of Pizza: Day 27a, 2025: Mikey's Late Night Slice (Columbus, OH)

exterior

DAY 27: OCTOBER 27th, 2025 - Part 1

LOCATION: Mikey's Late Night Slice (457 N High St, Columbus, OH 43215)

GUEST(S): Scott Wiener, Robin Rothman, Eidref Laxa, Denise Greer

ORDER: 1 slice of Pepperoni, 1/2 slice of Pepperoni & Banana Peppers, 1 slice of Spicy Pepperoni

REVIEW:

A Fun Hang in the Short North. Mikey’s Late Night Slice on North High Street is exactly what its name promises—and then some. Located in the heart of Columbus’s Short North neighborhood, this spot is equal parts pizza joint, art gallery, and late-night party. Between the cheeky décor, hidden secrets, and neon glow, there’s always something new to discover here—even before you get to the pizza. Upon entry, take note: the line on the right is for slices and pies, while the left-hand side leads to the bar. Choose your own adventure. The main floor is wide open with comfy booths and tables, but if you’re feeling adventurous, make your way downstairs to the hidden tiki speakeasy (or Tik-easy) bar tucked behind a walk-in freezer. That alone is worth the trip. The art on the walls is as playful as the atmosphere—look twice and you’ll catch the wandering eyes on a Ghostbusters II portrait, a not-so-subtle “coke” machine gag, and even a secret message or two. Mikey’s clearly doesn’t take itself too seriously... except when it comes to the pizza. Though the dough is made off-site, the thin crust pies hold up impressively well in the electric conveyor oven. Even the most topping-heavy specialty pizzas keep their crunch. I recommend keeping it classic with a spicy pepperoni slice—bonus points if you pair it with one of the excellent local beers on tap. No need to rush either; as the name suggests, Mikey’s is open late. So grab a slice, grab a drink, and soak in the vibe. Good pizza, good humor, and good times—Columbus-style.

PHOTOS:

slice options

back diningroom

pepperoni pie (cut in 12)

assorted other slices (cut smaller)

Day 27

underside

menuboard

gallery/hall to bathroom

hidden Tiki-speakeasy bar the "Tik-easy"

VIDEO:

link: https://www.tiktok.com/@31daysofpizza/video/7571318537663417631

MISCELLANEOUS:

Sean Taylor, Denise Greer, Mikey Sorboro, Scott Wiener, Eidref Laxa

1. Scott Wiener, who earlier this month made pizza for me in his apartment (link), is in Columbus, Ohio representing Slice Out Hunger - a non-profit dedicated to helping feed the hungry.

2. Eidref Laxa hosts a pizza related podcast called WHAT'S GOOD DOUGH?

3. Denise Greer also hosts a pizza related podcast called THE HOT SLICE. She works for Pizza Today the very people that decided that October should be National Pizza Month. Pizza Today are also the organizers of the Pizza Expo in Columbus and the International Pizza Expo in Las Vegas. I met Denise in Las Vegas at the Expo earlier this year and she interviewed me for THE HOT SLICE (episode link) where we discussed Pizza Month and prospect of her being my pizza guest in October.